Do you think it should be included only at the end of the examination process? Graduates’ gratitude: The generic structure of dissertation acknowledgements.Is it important for the examiner to know the candidate through the acknowledgement? And if you are an examiner as well- do you discuss this at all in your role as a supervisor- or leave it entirely to your student?
Do you think it should be included only at the end of the examination process? Graduates’ gratitude: The generic structure of dissertation acknowledgements.Is it important for the examiner to know the candidate through the acknowledgement? And if you are an examiner as well- do you discuss this at all in your role as a supervisor- or leave it entirely to your student? That is, it’s not the acknowledgements they are suspicious of but they are influenced by them and have a biased view on the acknowledgments.Tags: Persuasive Essay On Life AfterFree Accounting Homework Help OnlineMba Essay FormatDebt Assignment AgreementDartmouth Tuck Essays 2013Rejection Letters For Ed ApplicantsCustom Term Papers ReviewsPersuasive Essay On Romeo And Juliet
When my own student’s thesis was returned with compliments on the acknowledgments, I was interested in how the examiner reconciled this knowledge of the student with the result they awarded.
I was furious when a doctoral examiner was extremely critical of a single mother I knew by being picky on aspects which the other examiners commented were exemplary– I wanted to tell the examiner ! As an examiner myself, I become very inquisitive when a candidate writes paragraphs of praise for distant relatives and merely pens 2-3 lines on the supervisor.
Some examiners get irritated when names of top scholars whom the candidate probably met and chatted with at a conference are acknowledged with the hope of influencing the examiners.
Some examiners questioned the role of GOD in a thesis and want scientific evidence to support claims of divine assistance!
This became a research quest; I asked myself – are doctoral examiners influenced by the acknowledgments? But does this impact the final outcome of the thesis?
This curiosity led me to research this topic and resulted in a research project surveying 145 doctoral examiners that I describe in this paper.
If struggles are mentioned, there seems to be more formative and developmental feedback; otherwise, they tend to become less tolerant of mistakes and this may potentially mean becoming more “forensic” in examining the thesis.
Even though the examiners may be influenced, the good news is that most examiners say that the acknowledgments do not have an influence on the final outcome. What are your views of the acknowledgements in a thesis?
As an example, not mentioning the supervisors or not writing enough about the supervisors tends to be perceived as a lack of humility–the reaction to this is that the examiners tend to be less tolerant of the student’s mistakes.
On the contrary, some examines think that the supervisors should not be acknowledged at all until the successful completion of the thesis.